Bruce

Go towards the bottom of the page to see the top 21!

To celebrate the pending tenth anniversary of AVRev.com on July 1, 2006, AVRev.com has compiled its list of the top bands in rock history.

The Judges
The group of five judges included three Baby Boomers and two Generation Exers. The Boomers include former Dire Straits guitarist Jack Sonni, as well as University of Southern California Thornton School of Music professor Ken Lopez and AVRev.com’s music editor Charles Andrews. Desktop speaker company XHi-Fi president Howard Schilling and AVRev.com founder and publisher Jerry Del Colliano, Jr. round out the group.

The Method and Categories
From a diverse list of 100 bands, judges ranked each band for each category. A perfect score is 550 points. Using the analytical tools that have become popular in high-powered fantasy sports, the AVRev.com judges rated bands based on a battery of criteria.

U.S. Sales: (100 points max) Sales numbers come from the RIAA’s website and are ranked from 100 to 1 (with the top score going to The Beatles). These numbers are based in fact and therefore were not voted on or changed in any way by any of the judges.

Songs and Songwriting: (100 points max) Songwriting is key to the legacy of any band. In addition to songwriting, judges were encouraged to judge a band on how they interpreted songs in performance. The Jimi Hendrix Experience’s version of “All Along the Watchtower” or Van Halen’s “You Really Got Me” reflect the respective band’s ability to remake a great song, written by someone else, as their own.

Technical Ability: (100 points max) All too often, music critics overlook a band’s ability to play their asses off (think reviews of Nirvana), but not at AVRev.com. Having chops is a fully ranked, 100-point category.

Innovation: (100 points max) The ability to define a genre or a sound or a technique, or to strongly influence bands that came after you, make up the parameters for the fully-weighted innovation category.

Live Performance: (50 points max) Some members of the panel of judges have actually played with or opened for a number of the bands on the list. Ken Lopez’s story of jamming with Jimi Hendrix at the Guild booth before the 1967 Monterey Pop Festival is an all-time classic rock story. Our team of judges look at how good a band is playing live based loosely on their draw, seeing the band live or watching them on video.

Consistency vs. Longevity: (50 points max) This is one of the most interesting categories, when you consider the role of the most critically acclaimed bands during the history of rock. Bands like The Eagles rank high in this category because they had a long run as a top rock band, yet knew when to hang up the spurs. The Jimi Hendrix Experience, despite their short run, also did well, considering their three studio records. Even when Jimi let Noel Redding (the bass player) sing – the song was good. The Rolling Stones have many a landmark record in their history, but they also have many a stiff. Consider your own grade for bands like Genesis and Van Halen, who tried to go for a third front man with disastrous results to an otherwise spectacular career.

Random Play (50 points max): This category allows the judge to vote on a band based on how likely he is to listen to a band’s songs if they were to come up on an iPod. Many respected bands suffer in this category, whereas bands that are quietly a guilty pleasure (think The Bee Gees or The Carpenters) can get high grades.

Bands That Never Got Considered

It was a tough job to assemble the list of bands for consideration. It was essential that bands from the early days of the 1950s through today’s most popular acts were considered. We looked for diversity in genre and type. We included bands that were reggae, electronic, strong country/crossover and beyond. We did not consider individual artists such as Elvis or Michael Jackson, because this is an exercise in looking at the best bands. In the event an artist was associated with a stable band, judges were instructed to only consider his or her work with that band. An act like Prince and the Revolution was aided in that category, since “the artist formerly known as a vegan symbol record company slave” isn’t being judged.

Now - Onto the top 21


For the rest of the list, please visit: - ONLY REGISTERED AND ACTIVATED USERS CAN SEE ALL LINKS - CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Curb Zone

 

Choleric

Led Zeppelin = Amazingness

other than that #12 is good, #36 should be higher, so should 50 and 66.

Dont know why the hell #56 is so high, and how the hell did #100 even get on the list at all.

Oh and Radiohead should also definately be higher than #90.

Bruce

I agree, laughable.

BTW, how the hell did the Dixie Chicks make it to #43?

---

Anyways other than that, I think it's a pretty respectable list. Glad to see Rush within the top 15. Although, innovation a mere 77 points?

Can't say I agree with that one bit. Rush's instrumental mastery and constant style of music change should have meant they scored at least 90 in this category. My opinion of course..

Imhotep Evil

Yet another american perspective imposed as the all (by USA/RIAA sales ) time best.


Sorry, while I agree with many/most of the bands here, some are just not all time material IMO.

The Emperor

Metallica in the top 10? .....

Anisc

Somehow don't see sales being a good criteria for judging this. Some excellent alternate bands (which are not sales oriented) but have a huge cult following are left out of this list.....e.g. Phish, String Cheese Incident etc...
and what's with the Black Eyed Peas coming in at 100 as one of the greatest rock acts of all time !...????

Monster

Their old stuff are the best, new stuff are horrible. Their last album was rubbish.

Tool only gets 85/100 for technical ability... Nirvana is ranked too low. How the hell can Black Eyed Peas get on the top 100 Rock Band list? Aren't the Dixie Chicks a country music band?

The Emperor

100% agree with you!

Curb Zone